The Thanksgiving Pie Recipes season is just around the corner, and many people are starting to make their Thanksgiving dinner plans. Have you thought about what kind of pie you will be serving? Thanksgiving pies can be a great addition to your Thanksgiving meal. This blog post contains 20 delicious Thanksgiving pie recipes that have been tried and tested in many kitchens.
I have a confession to make, and don’t tell too many people! I know why I don’t do well with going on diets…I love desserts, most especially pies. During the month before Thanksgiving and Christmas times come around, I going on an almost starvation type of diet. I’m prepping myself for the onslaught on Holiday Binge eating! I can’t wait for this time of the year to come around.
Food brings people together. The stress of making a list of ingredients and planning the making all the food is so well worth it. Food not only helps create conversations, but it brings nourishment to the palates of the soul of everyone. You even get to swap recipes with other people who love to cook, and they HAVE to have your recipe and you HAVE to have theirs. It’s a win-win for everyone. But with dessert, it adds the finishing touch to everything, and everyone loves pie! In fact, everyone looks forward to having pie for dessert, at least they do in my family. It’s a level of expectation that I bring a couple of pies for dessert. This amazing list of pie recipes is going to make you a hit!
What is the history of Thanksgiving Pie?
Thanksgiving pie recipes have been around since the 1800s.
The Thanksgiving Pie tradition was a bit different than it is today: pies were served at Thanksgiving dinner, and they weren’t as sweet as they are now. These days Thanksgiving pies typically include pumpkin, apple, or pecan filling in a light crust that barely holds together with whipped cream, ice cream, or custard as the topping.
What is the most common Thanksgiving pie?
Apple pie is one of the world’s favorite pies and it has been a part of America for centuries now, but there are many other Thanksgiving pies that can be enjoyed in celebration today. Thanksgiving pie recipes will vary depending on where you live, but the most important of any recipe is they are delicious and have the flavors of Thanksgiving!
Here are some great recipes to try this Thanksgiving. From the classic pumpkin pie recipe to other desserts like apple cranberries crumb pie or cheesecake that is not your usual Thanksgiving dessert- there are plenty of options for an array of tastes!
20 Thanksgiving Pie Recipes
Pumpkin pie is a good dessert to serve on Thanksgiving. It is traditionally served in a large dish and cut into wedges. You can also serve it in different ways, such as individual cups of pumpkin pie with whipped cream or ice cream for people to enjoy. This is also good when having small gatherings.
This pumpkin cheesecake will make your Thanksgiving amazing. It has a spiced graham cracker crust and a filling made of cream cheese, eggs, sugar, and pumpkin puree. Add some whipped cream to finish it off!
The best part about the Snickers Turtle Pie is that it tastes like snicker and turtles candy. It is also important to note that this is a frozen pie. This pie will be 13 points for one serving size.
S’Mores Chocolate Pudding Pie is a dessert you can enjoy at any time of year. It has the taste of s’mores and chocolate pudding together. This recipe is easy to do, too.
Cheesecake is a favorite dessert for many people, and it’s perfect to make on Thanksgiving. Have you tried different flavors of cheesecake? This one has bananas in cream cheese and is gluten-free!
This apple pie has updated flavors. The taste will blow your mouth away! It goes well with vanilla ice cream.
Spiced sweet potato pie, with a buttery crust and fluffy toasted marshmallow meringue, is the perfect fall dish. It’s also one of my favorite Thanksgiving pie recipes!
Pumpkin Mousse Pie is a delicious dessert. It has 5 grams of fiber, 8 grams of protein, and only under 200 calories. You can’t go wrong with these stats at Thanksgiving to satisfy your sweet tooth craving.
You can never be too prepared for Thanksgiving! These Vegan pumpkin pie bites are quick and easy to make. They only have 2 ingredients.
I love sweet potato pie, it is delicious and not too unhealthy. It has butter in it but no eggs or cream. You can’t do anything wrong with your diet if you eat this pie.
The best dessert I have ever tasted is pecan pie cobbler. It tastes like a slice of delicious homemade pecan pie with buttery, cake-like crust on top that bakes into the perfect crunchy topping and creates caramel sauce!
Pie crusts are one of the most underrated parts of a pie. They can sometimes be extra calories that you don’t want to eat, so what is better than making your own crustless fruit pie?
Cranberry sauce is often leftover after Thanksgiving. But this recipe is the best way to use it for dessert! It is made like an upside-down cake with sweet cinnamon and allspice that people can eat any time they want.
This homemade banana cream pie is a great choice for a party. The crust and filling are made fresh, not from a can. It will be better than anything you can buy in the store because it has more flavor!
This pie is so easy! The filling can be made up to 3 days ahead of time. If you also prepare the crust in advance, all that’s left for you to do when it comes time to bake is put the pie together.
Cranberry White Chocolate Cheesecake is a dessert that you can enjoy at any time of year. It has cranberries which are tart, cheesecake which is creamy and sweet, and white chocolate which is sweet. You can have it before the holidays or after them.
This pie is made with an easy homemade crust that has fresh apples and cranberries in it. It’s topped with a crumbly cinnamon-sugar mixture that you will want to eat just by tasting it!
This peanut butter pie recipe is perfect for any party. It has a graham cracker crust, smooth peanut butter filling with cream cheese and chocolate ganache on top. You need to chill it overnight so that it can be the best dessert at the party!
19. Pumpkin Pie
What is a list of Thanksgiving pie recipes without sharing at least one recipe for the classic pumpkin pie? This pumpkin pie recipe is great because it has a smooth, rich taste that shines on a homemade crust and whipped cream.
20. Apple Pie
Thanksgiving is a time for family, friends, and desserts. Thanksgiving pie recipes are the perfect way to celebrate this holiday season with your loved ones! These delicious pies are sure to be a hit at any Thanksgiving dinner party or gathering.
November is the month for all things pumpkin. The smell of cinnamon and nutmeg in your home reminds you that Thanksgiving will be here before we know it. We hope these 20 delicious pie recipes inspire you to whip up something special this holiday season!
What’s Your Favorite Thanksgiving Pie Recipe? Send us pictures of it below in the comments section so we can add them to this list!