Myrtle Beach’s 13 Best Delis, According to Locals

Myrtle Beach is a haven for deli enthusiasts, offering a rich tapestry of flavors through its vibrant selection of sandwich shops. Locals who cherish a well-crafted sandwich know the best spots to indulge in layers of fresh ingredients and expert seasoning. From hearty Italian subs to authentic Polish treats, these delis provide both traditional tastes and innovative combinations. Each one deserves a visit for those seeking quality, satisfaction, and culinary finesse in their sandwich experience.

Dagwood’s Deli: A Sandwich Lover’s Dream

Dagwood’s Deli establishes itself as a cornerstone for anyone passionate about sandwiches. Known for generously stacked creations, each one is crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients that ensure every bite bursts with flavor. Their signature offering, the “Dagwood,” layers assorted meats, cheeses, and crisp vegetables between freshly baked bread, achieving a balance that is both filling and delectable. Attention to detail in slicing and proportion elevates their sandwiches, making each visit a culinary delight.

Kaminsky’s: Taste of New York

Kaminsky’s brings a slice of New York to Myrtle Beach with its authentic array of deli offerings. Known for their dense and flavorful pastrami on rye, each sandwich is meticulously prepared, featuring house-cured meats that are tender and well-seasoned. Emphasizing quality and tradition, Kaminsky’s perfects the art of the classic deli experience. Whether you prefer a Reuben or a simple turkey sandwich, the careful balance of textures and flavors highlights the genuine New York deli spirit.

Pulaski Deli: Polish Perfection

Pulaski Deli offers an authentic taste of Poland through its expertly prepared sandwiches and deli specialties. Traditional Polish meats and cheeses, such as kielbasa and smoked ham, are the stars here, nestled in crusty bread for a satisfying meal. Their use of house-made condiments like spicy mustard and tangy pickles complements the richness of the meats, bringing a nuanced depth to each bite. Pulaski Deli is a must-visit for those seeking hearty, flavorful fare with a European twist.

Toffino’s: Italian Artisan Sandwiches

Toffino’s stands out with its dedication to Italian culinary traditions, reflected in their carefully crafted artisan sandwiches. The focus is on premium ingredients like imported Italian cold cuts, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil, layered within freshly baked, ciabatta-style bread. Their signature Italian sub showcases a harmonious blend of flavors, enhanced by a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil and a sprinkle of sea salt. For those appreciating authenticity and subtlety in Italian cuisine, Toffino’s delivers on every front.

Joey Doggs: The Hot Dog Haven

Joey Doggs excels in crafting hot dogs that delight with every bite. Known for their perfect snap, the sausages are encased in natural casing that provides an irresistible texture. Each dog can be customized with a variety of toppings, including chili, onions, and shredded cheese, allowing diners to tailor each bite to their taste. The buns here are steamed to soft perfection, cradling the hot contents without becoming soggy. Pairing the dogs with their freshly made fries, which are twice-cooked for optimal crispiness, ensures a satisfying dining experience.

Crepe Creation Café: Beyond Crepes

While famous for its buttery, golden-brown crepes, Crepe Creation Café offers an array of savory and sweet dishes that extend beyond the crepe. The menu features inventive combinations, such as smoked salmon with dill cream cheese and capers. Each dish is carefully assembled to balance flavors and textures, resulting in a memorable culinary experience. Attention to detail is evident in the use of fresh herbs and quality fillings. Diners are encouraged to explore these options, enjoying the café’s commitment to both tradition and innovation.

Bagel Factory: Bagels and Beyond

Bagel Factory delivers a quintessential New York bagel experience with a Southern twist. Boiled and baked to achieve the perfect crust, their bagels boast a chewy interior that pairs well with a variety of spreads and fillings. Beyond breakfast, the menu offers hearty sandwiches stacked with deli meats, fresh vegetables, and artisanal cheeses. An emphasis on sourcing local ingredients ensures freshness and quality. Bagel Factory's thoughtful preparation makes it a go-to spot for those seeking both classic and contemporary flavors.

Lenny’s Sub Shop: Classic Subs

Lenny’s Sub Shop is renowned for its dedication to the art of the sub. Each sandwich is meticulously crafted, starting with freshly baked bread that provides the ideal foundation. Their classic Italian sub features thinly sliced salami, capicola, and pepperoni, complemented by crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes. With condiments like vinegar and oil for added zing, every layer contributes to a harmonious whole. Lenny’s stands out for its consistency and quality, making it a favorite among sub aficionados seeking reliability and flavor.

Manny's Deli & Subs: Gourmet Goodness

Manny’s Deli & Subs is a true Myrtle Beach favorite, known for its no-frills charm and generously packed sandwiches. Locals rave about the fresh-baked bread, piled-high meats, and house-made sauces that give each sub a signature touch. Whether you go for a classic Italian, a hot pastrami, or a custom creation, Manny’s delivers flavor and value in every bite. It’s the kind of spot where regulars are known by name—and keep coming back.

Bagel Port Cafe and Deli: A Slice Above

Bagel Port Cafe and Deli is a hidden gem for those who crave a solid breakfast or lunch on the go. Known for its perfectly chewy, freshly baked bagels, this cozy spot serves up hearty breakfast sandwiches, deli classics, and rich coffee that keeps locals coming back. Whether you’re grabbing a bacon, egg, and cheese or a piled-high turkey club, Bagel Port delivers quality and comfort in every bite—all with friendly service and a laid-back vibe.

Little Pigs Bar-B-Q: Southern Sandwiches

Little Pigs Bar-B-Q brings authentic Southern charm to their sandwiches, featuring meats smoked to perfection. The pulled pork is tender, with a smoky essence that permeates throughout. Their coleslaw, a blend of crisp cabbage and a tangy dressing, provides a refreshing contrast to the richness of the meat. Bread selections range from soft rolls to hearty buns, each grilling just enough to achieve a light crisp texture. Seasoned with a signature barbecue sauce, these sandwiches capture the essence of Southern barbecue traditions, making each bite a memorable experience.

Jersey Mike's Subs: Cool Combos

Jersey Mike’s Subs has earned a loyal following in Myrtle Beach for its fresh, made-to-order sandwiches and signature “Mike’s Way” toppings. Each sub is built with premium meats and cheeses sliced right in front of you, served on soft, flavorful bread that ties it all together. Whether you go for a cold classic or a hot cheesesteak, the flavors are bold, the portions generous, and the quality consistent—making it a go-to spot for sandwich lovers who crave something better than basic.

Mr. Sub: Local Favorite

Mr. Sub is a longtime local favorite in Myrtle Beach, known for its old-school charm and straightforward, satisfying sandwiches. With fresh ingredients, soft rolls, and classic deli meats, it’s a no-nonsense spot where quality and consistency shine. Regulars love the friendly service and laid-back vibe, making it a reliable go-to for a quick lunch or casual bite. It’s the kind of place where the subs are stacked high—and the locals wouldn’t have it any other way.