My Instant Pot cheesy chicken and pasta dish I made last night was a HUGE hit with my family! My family is loving the Instant Pot, as I am able to get dinner done and served in under 30 minutes. That’s a HUGE sigh of relief in my home as I have such a busy day before trying to get dinner started. Time escapes me, and I wind up taking over 1 1/2 hours to making a full meal for my family. In fact, I have used my Instant Pot 3 times this week, and am planning on a fourth soon! This week I made Sausage & Peppers and then Tex Mex Chili in my Instant Pot. Go and grab the recipes because they’re super simple and definitely delicious!
Instant Pot Cheesy Chicken and Pasta dish is easy and delicious!

My family adores and chicken, and they love them some cheese. So of course, it was an easy thing to try to cook. The only thing that I was concerned about was, “What type of pasta” I should use. Common sense kicked in and told me that I would need a thick and hearty pasta too cook with the chicken. So I used an orecchiette bag of pasta that I already had on hand. You can use different pasta with it, such as penne and rigatoni.

Instant Pot Cheesy Chicken and Pasta dish is easy and delicious!

 

I hope you enjoy this super duper easy and delicious instant pot cheesy chicken and pasta recipe!

**Please Note: I use an 8qt Instant Pot with all of my recipes. Your recipe will turn out differently if you use a 6qt. It’s also very important to allow your Instant pot to cool off for 5 minutes after using the sauté function. This is for the safety of your machine, as it could short the wiring in your IP. Whether you use my recipe or another recipe that instructs you to use the sauté function on the IP, you will need to allow it to cool. This information can be found via the IP website or customer service.

Instant Pot Cheesy Chicken And Pasta
Recipe Type: Entree
Author: David Murphy
Prep time:
Cook time:
Total time:
Serves: 8
Ingredients
  • Approximately 2 pounds of skinless boneless chicken breasts cut into 1″ chunks (Approximately 5 breasts)
  • 1 tablespoon of EVOO
  • 4 tablespoons of salted butter
  • 1 bag of orecchiette pasta (1 pound bag)
  • 2 cups of whole milk
  • 2 cups of water
  • 1 tablespoon of yellow mustard
  • 1 teaspoon sea salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
  • 6 cups of shredded mild cheddar cheese
Instructions

 

Instant Pot Cheesy Chicken And Pasta

Preparation 5 mins Inactive Time 00:05 Cook Time 19:00 Total Time 19:05
Serves 8     adjust servings

 

Ingredients

  • Approximately 2 pounds of skinless boneless chicken breasts cut into 1
  • 1 tablespoon of EVOO
  • 4 tablespoons of salted butter
  • 2 1/2 cups of uncooked orecchiette pasta. If using a 6 quart IP, use 2 cups
  • 2 cups of whole milk. If using a 6 quart IP, use 1 cup
  • 2 cups of water
  • 1 tablespoon of yellow mustard
  • 1 teaspoon sea salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
  • 6 cups of shredded mild cheddar cheese If using a 6 quart IP, use 4 cups

Instructions

  1. With your IP on sauté, add in olive oil. Wait until it's heated and add in your 1" cubed chicken chunks.
  2. Cook for approximately 4 minutes. I just wanted a little seared color on them.
  3. Add in all remaining ingredients (except milk and cheese) and close your IP lid. Please be sure to mix the pasta in with the chicken and liquid in your IP. This will help your pasta cook more evenly. Set on Manual High Pressure for 12 minutes. QR (Quick pressure Release) when done.
  4. Add in milk and cheese. Set on Manual High Pressure for 2 minutes.
  5. When it's done, do a NPR (Natural Pressure Release for 7 minutes) and then QR. If you do a QR at first, some liquids might squirt out with the steam. Mix well when you remove IP lid. PLEASE NOTE: There will be a tiny bit of "scorching" at the bottom of your IP because of the milk and cheese. I didn't find it to be too horrible, I just didn't scrape the bottom...but I wanted to be honest with you all.

by

Recipe Notes

 Please note: The type of pasta I used is VERY dense. If you're using other types of pasta, your cooking time will be different. 

1 review

As you can see, I am just wanting to sear off the chicken for a few minutes to give it a little color.

You will not have made an easier or delicious meal in your Instant Pot. My Instant Pot cheesy chicken and pasta is going to be a HUGE hit in your home, too! Please note: That there will be some slight charring at the bottom due to the dairy products, but it’s not really bad. It’s just a little bit, which is why it’s important to layer pasta on top of the chicken, and then the layer of cheese on top.

Get My FREE Instant Pot Recipes eBook!
Enter your email address and click on the Get Instant Access button.
We respect your privacy
Previous articleInstant Pot Sausage and Peppers
Next articleInstant Pot Pinto Beans and Bacon

II love creating fun, easy, and delicious recipes for everyone in the family to enjoy and make. With my family of 9 (11 if you count my two pups!), I have to make meals for all different tastes and in a short amount of time. When I’m not busy cooking, I’m taking care of my special needs sister, Angela..which you can read all about our journey!

32 COMMENTS

  1. I am hoping that I add the pasta, milk and cheese in step #4. It does not say to add the pasta in this step however.

    • Sorry about that! I made an edit to it earlier to correct a misspelling, and forgot to write pasta back in it lol.

  2. I just had a major recipe fail and think the directions need a tune-up—it says in step 3 to add everything except milk and cheese and then in step 4 says to add PASTA, milk and cheese. I added the pasta in step 3. 🙁

  3. So I am a brand new instant pot user. I chose this recipe b/c it appeared very easy. I don’t know what happened (other than absolute user error). It turned out very watery and the cheese curdled. Can you help a newby out?

    • Did you use enough pasta? This is a thick and hearty type of pasta, and you have to use a thick and hearty type of pasta to “soak up the liquid”. For the cheese, I’ve not ever heard of shredded cheese curdling before. 6 Cups of cheese = 3 8oz bags of cheddar cheese. So just double check that. Hope this helps!

    • Did you use cold milk? Cold milk added to a hot liquid will curdle! Try warming milk a little in microwave before adding next time and see if that doesn’t help!

  4. I just want to double check because it has been misunderstood in the past. Do you have to cook the pasta before adding it in? Or add in the uncooked bag ?

    • Hi Erica! I’m sorry for a delayed response, but I was in the middle of moving into my new home. Oh the stress of it all lol! However, you put the pasta in uncooked!

  5. Hi David,

    I tried this tonight and ran into some issues, but I want to make sure it’s actually different than how it turns out for you.

    I used 1 lb of fusilli pasta and it ended up very much al dente. Is this normal?

    Like another reviewer, I had curdling happen too, though I’m fairly certain it was the milk and not the cheese. I don’t suspect this affected flavor but did affect the texture, making it feel very grainy. Is this different than what you get?

    As for the “liquidy” comments, mine also seemed very watery at first but thickened pretty quickly upon cooling, for whatever that’s worth! Thanks for your help!

    • Hi Caitlin! I apologize for a delayed response, as I just moved and am finishing up some more unpacking. If it turns out too al dente, place the lid back on your IP and seal it. Wait for about 5 minutes, and the steam and hot cheesy liquid will cook it for you. No Need to turn the IP back 🙂 It’s why I love the IP so much! <3 However, I didn't experience any curdling, so I'm wondering if this is happening from different elevations. I will have a few friends from around the country help me test this theory. Thank you so much for trying out my recipe!

  6. Pasta was super AL dente almost hard. I followed directions perfectly. Is this how it comes out. Not much scorching though:)

    • Yay for no scorching!! <3 If it turned out super al dente, you can always just put the lid back on it and close for about 5 minutes so it can cook a little bit more from the steam and hot cheesy liquid. No need to turn the IP back on.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here